Margin Notes

FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: MULTICOMPONENT READING INTERVENTION

Oct
29

“Using a supplemental, multicomponent reading intervention to increase adolescent readers’ achievement” by Margaret Osgood Opatz and Sarah Kocherhans (The Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy, 2024)

“Instructional guidelines recommend implementing multicomponent interventions, those that address multiple reading skills (e.g., word analysis, fluency), because they yield better results than isolated skill interventions (Edmonds et al., 2009). Isolated skill intervention is insufficient for reading mastery, particularly for secondary students, who are expected to apply decoding skills to challenging text (Archer et al., 2003; Scammacca at al., 2007). Once students master decoding, other factors become more prominent in their reading development (Buckingham, 2020). While content courses in secondary schools place high expectations on students’ reading comprehension, foundational skills may impede students’ achievement. Therefore, it is imperative that adolescent readers progress toward proficient reading quickly, and that interventions target all of the major aspects of reading, as informed by research on effective practices.”

Summary

In this article, Osgood Opatz and Kocherans share the results of their study on the impact of a yearlong multicomponent small group reading intervention on the reading achievement of 7th grade students reading below grade level.

They situate their research within the unique reading demands placed on adolescent readers: “By middle school, readers are confronted with complex, disciplinary texts that differ markedly from everyday language and are, therefore, more cognitively demanding.” Adolescent comprehension relies heavily on the integration of linguistic and cognitive processes:

  • decoding multisyllabic words
  • comprehending increasingly complex language, including understanding vocabulary, various sentence constructions, and disciplinary strategies
  • morphological awareness to unpack the meaning in condensed words
  • syntactic awareness to identify the way phrases and clauses within sentences work together to construct meaning
  • integrating background knowledge and making inferences

Osgood Opatz and Kocherans base the components of their multicomponent model on the four recommendations made in the Providing Reading Interventions for Students in Grades 4–9 Educator’s Practice Guide. These include interventions focused on multisyllabic words, fluency, and comprehension with materials that include complex, connected text. For secondary readers, interventions should focus on complex text reading with appropriate supports, fluency, multisyllabic word reading, and vocabulary with interspersed comprehension work.

Scaffolding complex text reading: Students should engage with connected, complex text, which is at least one grade level above their instructional reading level to maximize gains.

Fluency: In addition to assisted reading of complex text, repeated reading of the same text improves reading fluency.

Multisyllabic word reading: Instruction in syllable types and vowel sounds equips adolescent readers with word analysis skills they can apply as they encounter complex texts in any content area classes, which ultimately supports fluency.

Vocabulary: Intervention must target highly frequent, academic vocabulary to support comprehension and it must incorporate vocabulary review to provide multiple, meaningful exposures.

Comprehension: Open-ended comprehension questioning should be incorporated throughout the passage-reading portions of an intervention to support and deepen students’ Understanding.

While typical students would be expected to improve their reading ability by 1 year during a school year, it is critical that students reading below grade level improve at a faster rate to close the gap. The participants in this study reported growth equivalent to more than 1 year.

Takeaways For the Classroom

  • Avoid isolated skill instruction and leverage multicomponent strategy instruction that focuses on fluency, word reading, vocabulary, and comprehension.
  • Provide students with scaffolds that allow them to access and to practice in challenging grade-level complex texts.
  • Leverage the interdependent relationship between reading strategies by modelling and practicing how readers use them flexibly.
  • Prioritize acceleration by developing necessary scaffolds for students to engage with complex text and not the remediation of isolated skills dissociated from authentic text.
  • Use PLC time to co-plan consistent multi-component instruction and intervention for students across all disciplines.

Conclusion

“Adolescent learners who enter secondary school reading below grade level have generally experienced years of reading instruction that has failed them. The gaps in foundational knowledge may vary widely between students, due to the differing instruction received in the elementary grades. To best support adolescent learners, intervention must target multiple areas in which reading failure may occur while simultaneously immersing students in complex text, as complex text reading prepares students for the text they will encounter in content area classes.”

FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: POEM OF THE DAY

Apr
30

“’Every day do something that won’t compute’: Student perceptions of a daily poetry practice” by Megan Davis (The Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy, 2023)

“Grounded in the central question, what happens to student perceptions of poetry when class begins each day with a poem?, this study wonders about the student experience on the other end of a teacher’s (my own) attempt to diverge from a sterilized literary atmosphere seemingly antithetical to enjoyment or appreciation…As a granular and personal look at student experiences with a daily poetry ritual, this study aims to invite its readers to consider the ways in which more expansive and regular encounters with poetry might be a worthwhile possibility for the literacy classroom.”

Summary

In this article, Megan Davis describes how her experiences with a daily poetry ritual as a high school student led her to adopt a poem of the day (POTD) practice as an ELA teacher. When she became a doctoral student at Columbia University, Davis decided to revisit the practice as a researcher:

Simply, I wanted to know how this poetry practice differed from traditional, analytical approaches to poetry and what it meant—if anything—for my students. I was curious how students experienced what I presumed was a significant lacuna of response-based pedagogies within contemporary secondary English Language Arts classrooms, fettered by the kind of literary engagement endemic to and aggrandized by the mechanized, impersonal environment of high-stakes testing and standardization. Was tasking students with doing something other than analysis with a poem as counter-cultural as I thought it would be? What is the effect of daily exposure to poetry in this way? Was it powerful? Did they just zone out?

Davis’ research into POTD as a pedagogical practice includes a literature review, interviews with three former students, and considerations for classroom practice.

Her review of research revealed specific disconnects related to poetry instruction. First, teachers believe that poetry holds an important place in ELA instruction but often do not feel they have adequate knowledge and skill to teach it. Second, teachers’ expressions of personal enjoyment of poetry contrasts with their avoidance or dislike of it in the classroom. Third, teachers express student engagement with and enjoyment of poetry as their goal for instruction, yet they feel this is often overshadowed by traditional poetry practices such as writing detailed analyses.

To explore the impact of a daily poetry ritual, Davis conducted two interviews with three former students. The first round of interviews focused on their experiences with POTD and poetry perceptions throughout their K-12 education. The second round inquired about the participants’ “present-tense poetry engagement” to ascertain the lasting effects of POTD. Davis compiled the qualitative data from the interviews into three categories: history and prior perceptions of poetry, poem of the day, and current poetry perceptions.

Takeaways For the Classroom

  • The interviews revealed “pervasive misconceptions about poetry: that it is a teacher’s vehicle to teach literary devices, that it is old and boring, that it must rhyme, that it is for highly uncomfortable levels of self-disclosure, and that is rigid and restrictive insomuch that it impedes creative freedom.” These misconceptions were shaped by the participants’ school encounters with poetry prior to POTD.
  • After POTD, all three participants described a “pattern of rewriting their prior judgements as a result or repeated aesthetic transactions with poetry: poetry is not as weird, inflexible, dull, emotional, scary, gimmicky, or nonacademic as they had once thought.”
  • In every interview, participants remarked that, because of POTD, they found poems they could relate to. Offering a wide range of poetry in terms of form, poet, era, topic, theme, and style is “a way to provide a host of landing points.”
  • Participants’ stories revealed the “potential a non-analytic reading practice has to reshape student perceptions of poetry, reorient them to freedom of expression in poetic language, and invite them into new ways of seeing and engaging in their lives with heightened poetic awareness.”

Conclusion

“Though reading students a poem each day to start class will not solve all resistance to poetry, I am convinced that it opens up an invitation for authentic, wide-ranging, and consistent experiences with poetry for student and teacher. Students are not often afforded the opportunity to enjoy a piece of literature, to spend time with it as human beings, before they are asked to do something ‘school’ with it.”

FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: READING MOTIVATION

Mar
26

“The Relationship Between Situated Reading Motivation and Perception of the Learning Environment for Adolescent Students” by Travis VanderVelden and Xornam Apedoe (The Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy, 2025)

“Reading motivation is defined in this study according to the consensus definitions put forward by Conradi et al. (2014) as ‘the drive to read resulting from a comprehensive set of an individual’s beliefs and attitudes toward, and goals for reading’ (p.154). Motivation to read has been shown to be an important predictor of reading performance and growth and there have been a variety of motivational interventions, specifically targeting reading motivation for adolescent students (McBreen and Savage 2021; Toste et al. 2020).”

Summary

In this article, VanderVelden and Apedoe make the link between reading achievement and motivation while encouraging a more contextualized and dynamic view of reading motivation. Because they consider motivation to be a function of the discipline and/or classroom where the reading event occurs, their research focuses on context-specific reading motivation. For this study, they define the learning environment as “everything from the physical layout of the classroom to the social-emotional components, such as teaching and learning practices, relationships between teachers and students, and the goals and values of the class.”

The authors acknowledge, however, that although the classroom environment provides important contexts for learning, adolescent readers bring with them unique identities, backgrounds, and reading habits that impact their reading habits and experiences. In their view, reading motivation is a characteristic of the reader and is acted upon by the text and context.

Two research questions guided their study:

  1. To what extent does reading motivation vary across content areas?
  2. To what extent does student perception of aspects of the learning environment influence situated reading motivation within different content areas?

They surveyed a sample of 1939 students at a large urban high school across four content areas: English, Social Science, Science, and Math. Motivation was measured by reading curiosity and reading involvement, and students’ perception of the learning environment was measured by student cohesiveness, teacher support, involvement, and investigation.

The results revealed clear differences between content areas and reading motivation. The authors theorize that this variation in motivation may stem from the different types of texts and purposes for reading students experience across subjects. They also revealed that the most impactful aspect of learning environment on motivation is investigation. The more perceived emphasis on problem-solving and inquiry, the more students felt individually motivated to read.

Takeaways For the Classroom

The results of this study reveal a direct relationship between classroom environment and motivation that has implications for classroom practice:

  • Frame texts as tools for solving problems or answering compelling questions.
  • Replace or supplement textbook reading with current authentic text from the discipline.
  • Develop text sets around thematic inquiries.
  • Integrate reading into authentic problem-solving scenarios by incorporating data infographics.

Conclusion

“The present findings show that in all content areas students are more motivated to read in a class when they perceive that the learning environment places more of an emphasis on investigation. This indicates that reading motivation is less affected by teachers and more significantly impacted by the nature of the class and the activities.

As students move into secondary education, reading becomes a crucial skill to succeed in most subjects, and simultaneously more nuanced and difficult to master. For many students who are unprepared to meet those reading demands, motivation is key to ensuring that they remain engaged.”

FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: SENTENCE COMPREHENSION

Feb
12

“A Closer Look at Close Reading: Three Under-the-Radar Skills Needed to Comprehend Sentences” by Heidi Anne Mesmer and M.M. Rose-McCully (The Reading Teacher, 2017)

“Close reading requires unpacking the implicit relationships within and across sentences. However, beyond the close-reading rage, students need to understand the ways writers cleverly use structures to add interest, description, and parsimony to their writing.”

Summary

In this article, Mesmer and Rose-McCully, highlight the impact of sentence-level comprehension on overall reading comprehension. They focus on three specific sentence constructions that can be taught explicitly to support students’ understanding of text.

  1. Anaphora is when one word or group of words replaces another within a sentence or across sentences. Pronouns are the simplest kinds of anaphoric relationships. The word(s) being replaced in anaphoric relationships are called antecedents because they come before the replacing words. Authors use anaphora for description, variety, and parsimony in their writing.
  2. Connectives explicitly link one clause to another (for example and, but, that, and which) or connect two adjacent sentences (such as however or thus). Because different connectives suggest different relationships, they signal to the reader that they must make a text-based inference.
  3. Appositives are nouns, noun phrases, or noun clauses that are set off by commas and immediately follows a noun. An appositive renames the noun and provides more information about it.

 

Takeaways For the Classroom

The authors provide a variety of practical strategies for explicitly teaching and practicing each structure:

Anaphora

  • Model and practice using highlighters to identify pronoun replacements and colour-code their relationships.
  • Create Mad-Lib style games for students to fill in nouns or pronouns.
  • Provide students with sentences containing pronoun replacements and have them work in small groups to creative descriptive noun replacements for the pronouns while maintaining the anaphoric relationships.

Connectives

  • Create cloze activities by giving students a portion of text they will be reading with the connectives removed. Ask them to select connectives from a bank of options based on the context of the sentence.
  • Provide students with sentence parts and have them work in partnerships to join them with connectives.
  • Practice sentence combining by having students use connectives to combine shorter sentences into a longer complex sentence.

Appositives

  • Provide students with sentences containing lengthy or multiple appositives. Ask them to cross out the appositives and see if they can make meaning from the sentence without it.
  • Invite students to create a list of nouns they can use to describe themselves and then write a descriptive paragraph using appositive phrases.
  • Create appositive poetry by asking students to pick an object and write a four-line poem about it using appositive phrases.

Conclusion

“…we have come to see connectives, appositives, and anaphora as being crucial to sophisticated reading and writing in the upper grades and beyond…students must use these structures in their own writing, transfer their knowledge to authentic materials, and begin to spot the clever ways that writers use these tools.”

FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: EXPLICITLY TEACHING LISTENING

Jan
15

“Explicitly Teaching Listening in the ELA Curriculum: Why and How” (The English Journal, 2020)

“We may assume that listening comes naturally from the process of learning other things. However, research suggests that ‘the better one can listen, the more educated one can become, and the more educated one becomes, the better one can listen…Listening leads to education and education leads to listening’ (Rice and Burbules 2740). Unfortunately, we have not focused enough attention on listening as a distinct skill to be taught, learned, practiced, and assessed (Parker 2816). This skill develops and grows more complex as our thinking and learning become more complex—that is, we do not stop developing as listeners just as we never stop growing as writers and readers. Instruction must be ongoing and develop more complexity as students’ skills in this area increase.”

Summary

According to the author, “listening is the foundation of the other language arts and is fundamental to all learning” and is directly linked to reading comprehension and overall school success. As such, we should be explicitly teaching listening in the ELA classroom.

Alford identifies three realities that have led to a diminished focus on listening as part of the ELA curriculum:

  • Teaching the act of listening has been an ignored area of research.
  • ELA standards prioritize reading and writing.
  • These is a lack of resources available to support teaching listening.

Good listeners demonstrate three essential skills that we can teach, model, and practice as part of our ELA curriculum:

  1. They can summarize what they have heard and identify the most relevant information.
  2. They connect what they have heard to themselves, their prior learning, and other texts.
  3. They are able to visualize, which deepens their listening in a multimodal way.

Takeaways For the Classroom

There are several ways teachers can embed active listening and build communities that values listening:

  • Teach, assign, assess, and provide feedback on listening explicitly.
  • Make listening an active process.
  • Use wait time.
  • Avoid restating what your students say, which reduces their responsibility to listen to one another.
  • Encourage students to respond to one another’s ideas.
  • Establish listening guidelines early in the year and practice them frequently.
  • Model good listening.
  • Teach notetaking.
  • Create more opportunities for group and partner work.
  • Invite students to talk about what they see effective listeners doing.
  • Provide models for what positive discussions look like.
  • Check for understanding by asking students to rephrase what you have said.

Conclusion

“Listening is a skill to be explicitly taught, practiced, and assessed. It is a political act that, if done well, can foster a sense of agency in our students. When they know how to listen well, they can engage more richly in public debate, and it builds a conscious awareness of all they hear and see in our world. We have focused too narrowly on giving voice to our students, and we have forgotten to provide them with a listening ear.”

FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: READING MOTIVATION

Nov
27

It’s not just about skills: Adopting a motivation-informed approach to instruction with adolescents by Kristin Conradi Smith, Bong Gee Jang, and Tori J. Ostot (Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 2024)

“Motivation, literally rooted in the Latin word “movere” has to do with what moves us to do something. When we talk about reading motivation, thus, we’re really considering what compels or inclines a student to participate (or not participate) in the reading activity or task. Though some research suggests that adolescents can be profiled as being highly motivated, ambivalent, or having low motivation (Syal et al., 2024), other research suggests the relationship is less clear and more context dependent (Retelsdorf et al., 2024). In fact, it is important to consider the dynamic and context-dependent nature of motivation, rather than relying solely on static categories that might inadvertently lead to deficit-oriented perceptions of students.”

Summary

While motivation-informed approaches benefit all students, the authors center this article on recent research with a particular focus on adolescents who have had struggles with reading and on students from diverse cultural and linguistic backgrounds who have often been ignored in research. This research confirms that students who have struggled with reading tend to avoid reading and perceive it as too difficult. These perspectives are considered “undermining motivation.”

Situated expectancy value theory (SEVT) suggests that students are motivated by whether they expect to be successful with a task or activity and whether they value it. Situational aspects of reading motivation include the purpose for reading, reading locations, text genres, and text topics.

A variety of factors have been identified as fostering adolescent readers’ motivation; however, two aspects matter most when designing and delivering instruction and interventions for adolescents:

  1. Interest and Relevance
  • In a meta-analysis of over 39 motivation-related interventions, interest played the most important role in improving students’ intrinsic motivation and achievement.
  • When students are given choice in reading materials and those materials align with their interests and cultural backgrounds, they are more likely to engage with the text, resulting in higher comprehension and retention.
  • Students see the relevance of what they are reading when teachers select texts that reflect relatable topics and themes.
  • This is especially important for students who have been marginalized by conventional educational practices—the lack of culturally relevant texts leads to diminished engagement in reading and writing.
  1. Self-beliefs
  • Students’ self-efficacy (their estimation of whether they can complete a task) and their perceptions of difficulty (whether they believe the task at hand will be too difficult for them) play a substantial role in motivation.
  • Teachers can address students’ self-beliefs by:
    • ensuring students feel confident they can access text
    • incorporating goal-setting strategies so students know expectations
    • providing positive and specific feedback

Takeaways For the Classroom

The authors identify four key principles for teachers to keep in mind when working with adolescent learners:

  1. Adopt an assets-based approach to classwork and assignments.
  • An assets-based approach means recognizing and valuing students’ diverse identities and funds of knowledge.
  • Teachers should make it a priority to recognize students’ strengths and potentials and design classroom activities and assignments to create opportunities for success and confidence-building.
  • Emphasizing the importance of developing and applying their strengths fosters a growth mindset in students, which increases engagement, perseverance, and academic achievement.
  • In an intervention setting, rather than starting the lesson with a focus on what students don’t know, approach it instead by highlighting previous skills mastered and connect what students already know to the new learning.

 

  1. Acknowledge the role of self-efficacy.
  • Self-efficacy is a student’s judgement about whether they will be successful with a given task. This expectancy is a major factor in students’ motivation.
  • Breaking assignments into concrete steps and providing actionable directions means that students can experience small successes along the way.
  • This is further supported by providing growth-oriented and specific feedback.
  1. Ground learning in meaningful texts and tasks.
  • Organizing text sets around themes or issues that are important to readers encourages them to make text-to-text and text-to-self connections, which increases engagement.
  • Incorporating an element of choice related to the tasks students will participate in during and after reading allows students to select tasks that are meaningful or interesting to them.
  1. Capitalize on opportunities for language use.
  • Relationships influence students’ motivation for engaging with reading.
  • Adolescents in particular are motivated when they work with each other.
  • Participation in book clubs has been shown to increase engagement and reading comprehension.

Conclusion

“As we consider working with adolescents who still need work on foundational skills, we would do them a particular disservice if we ignored the key roles that motivation will play in facilitating that learning.”

FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: LITERACY STRATEGY INSTRUCTION

Oct
30

“What Does It Take to Create Skilled Readers? Facilitating the Transfer and Application of Literacy Strategies” by Douglas Fisher and Nancy Frey (Voices from the Middle, 2008)

“Our concern is that these strategies are becoming ‘curricularized.’ By this, we mean that the strategies—rather than text—are becoming the center of instruction. One publisher even markets this curricularization by noting that the program teaches ‘one strategy at a time.’ We can’t find any evidence for the effectiveness of teaching one strategy at a time, especially with pieces of text that require readers to use a variety of strategies to successfully negotiate meaning.”

Summary

In this article, Fisher and Frey highlight the impact of the “super six” reading strategies that have come from the research on the behaviors of good readers—building background knowledge and making connections, predicting and inferring, questioning, monitoring, summarizing, and evaluating—on reading instruction. They express concerns over “curricularization” of the strategies which leads to teaching strategies one at a time and in isolation. This approach leads readers to a narrow and rigid understanding of how and when strategies should be used rather than creating the conditions for developing them to learn and apply strategies in a consolidated, authentic, and automatic way.

Instead, Fisher and Frey recommend a classroom structure that relies on the gradual release of responsibility: focus lessons, guided practice, collaborative learning, and independent learning.

The gradual release of responsibility model requires that learners experience multiple engagements with literacy strategies before they are expected to use them on their own. The authors believe that modeling is essential as it provides students with something to approximate as they attempt to become skilled readers. From their research, they have identified four categories of thinking for teachers to model:

  1. Comprehension: focus on the comprehension strategies for making meaning based on cluse from the text students will be reading.
  2. Vocabulary: model using word-solving strategies, including context clues, word parts (prefixes, suffixes, roots, bases, and cognates), and resources (people, the Internet, and dictionaries).
  3. Text Structures: identify the organizational structure of the text and note the signal words readers can use to support their understanding of the specific text structure as well as how they can use knowledge of the text structure to help them understand the text.
  4. Text Features: explain that text features (headings, captions, illustrations, charts, tables, graphs, table of contents, glossary, index, etc.) are added by authors and editors to help us understand the words and model how they aid comprehension.

Takeaways For the Classroom

  • Examine the text students will be reading to identify its complexity and use this as the basis for strategy instruction. Teach and model for students the strategies they will use to comprehend the text.
  • Use the gradual release framework to organize reading instruction. Begin with focused direct instruction that includes modeling, thinking aloud, and guided practice.
  • Provide students time for authentic independent practice in text and for collaboration with peers.
  • Ensure there is time for a debrief so that students can discuss, share, and consolidate their thinking through discussion and writing about reading.
  • Be explicit that readers consolidate strategies and model what this looks like in multicomponent strategy instruction. Design activities that promote the use of multiple strategies and not single strategies in isolation.

Conclusion

“These teachers understood that skilled readers are able to consolidate strategies and activate them at appropriate times. They also understood that the modeling phase of instruction presented an ideal time to demonstrate how a skilled reader could apply several comprehension strategies simultaneously in order to make meaning. This modeling encourages students to transfer their learning of strategies to an increasingly consolidated practice. Furthermore, the gradual release of responsibility framework promotes application to ne texts, resulting over time in skilled readers who activate strategies automatically.”

 

FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: CLASSROOM DISCUSSION

Jan
30

What Do I Say Next? Using the Third Turn to Build Productive Instructional Discussions by Evelyn Ford-Connors and Dana A. Roberston (Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 2017)

“After an initiating question or remark and subsequent student response, the next turn in the discussion typically belongs to the teacher, and it is at this juncture that teachers can extend students’ thinking as they probe, clarify, provide feedback, prompt elaboration, or hold the ideas up for others to consider. By picking up on students’ ideas, teachers explicitly connect them to lesson content and important concepts while also maintaining a cumulative progression of relevant ideas rather than vaguely connected student remarks. Simultaneously, teachers’ uptake of student contributions positions students as capable participants in academic life. Thus, through this strategic use of the third turn, teachers have the opportunity to help students build new knowledge; if we want to use classroom discussions as sites for new learning rather than displays of what students already know, we need to talk to them differently.”

Summary

In this article, Evelyn Ford-Connors and Dana A. Robertson share the findings from their research into the specific types of teacher talk that promote productive discussions. They define discussions as “the instructional exchanges that occur between teachers and students” and talk moves as “the various ways teachers can use talk within these discussions.”

Classroom discussions frequently follow an IRF pattern: the teacher initiates, a student responds, and the teacher follows up. The effectiveness of this pattern depends on “the purposes it is used to serve on particular occasions, and upon the larger goals, by which those purposes are informed.” Ford-Connors and Robertson look specifically at the third turn—teachers’ follow-up responses in this pattern—to identify the ways it can be used strategically to positively impact classroom discussion.

Third-turn talk moves fall into two categories. No single talk move is considered better than another. When teachers combine them with intention and base them on students’ ideas, discussion becomes more rigorous, and student learning is strengthened.

  1. Questioning: Although it is not limited to the third turn, research has shown that using certain types of questions in the third turn correlate with deeper understanding and higher learning outcomes.
  • High-Press Questioning- These questions are often open-ended and can be used in the third turn to probe students’ ideas, push for elaboration and clarity, foster critical analysis, and support deeper thinking about content. Research reveals that teachers’ use of high-press questioning impacts the rigor of a lesson and the degree of engagement and high-level thinking, especially when students are asked to relate their ideas to the text or to contributions from their classmates and to support their responses with text-based evidence. Longer periods of student engagement and more elaborated responses are associated with four questioning strategies:
    • Socratic Questioning (Prompting and guiding the discussion as it progresses)
    • Pumping (prompting for additional explanation and ideas)
    • Reflective toss (shifting an idea back to students for further consideration)
    • Constructive Challenge (questioning a students’ statement by asking for additional evidence or revision)
  • Low-Press Questioning- These are leading or narrowing questions that can be used in the third turn to scaffold students’ participation or to focus students’ attention on important information. Low-press questions often seek literal responses or offer choices.

The effectiveness of teacher questioning doesn’t depend on the use of high-press or low-press questioning. It results from the teacher’s questions being linked to what the student has said. The authors also note that the teacher is not solely responsible for forming questions and responses. When provided with models and opportunities to practice questioning, students will take the initiative to contribute to discussions with questions and comments on texts and content, becoming co-constructors of knowledge.

  1. Teacher Uptake: This quality of effective teacher talk in the third turn is associated with more productive discussions. Through uptake, teachers build on what has been said by incorporating a portion of the previous comment into their response.
  • Revoicing- When used as a third turn strategy, the teacher incorporates an aspect of the students’ comment to create a connection, elaborate on the student’s idea, recast the response in more academic terms (for example to model technical terms or vocabulary), or to open the discussion to further comments from others.
  • Elaborative Feedback- this type of response during the third turn includes some form of explanation or strategic information, redirection, or clarification to help students modify their performance. This type of feedback is most effective when it focuses on students’ correct or practically correct responses and adds to their previous attempts rather than focusing on incorrect responses.

Conclusions

“Using a broader repertoire of teacher talk moves in the third turn that includes high- and low-press questioning and uptake to revoice and elaborate students’ participation but also fosters students’ productive engagement with content, connects new vocabulary to essential concepts, and heightens the intellectual rigor of the classroom (Ford-Connors, 2011; Hattie & Timperley, 2007; Web et. al., 2008). This repertoire of talk moves and the flexibility with which skilled teachers employ them during discussions weave together students’ contributions with content and scaffold the learning e4xperience. At the same time, the language-rich interactions that occur when students and the teacher productively discuss content and grapple with ideas develop students’ capacity to think deeply about content and define the kinds of talk and thinking that are sanctioned in the classroom (Nystrand, 2006). In other words, as they manage their classroom’s discourse, teachers set the stage for how knowledge will be generated and shared, which in turn strengthens students’ opportunities to learn.”

Takeaways For the Classroom

  • Tune into what talk moves you currently use in the third turn during large-group, small-group, and one-on-one discussions and identify patterns.
  • Use high-press questions to probe ideas, encourage critical analysis, invite elaboration or clarification, and build new knowledge.
  • Use low-press questions to activate students’ background knowledge, scaffold students’ participation, focus students’ attention on specific information, and facilitate practice with vocabulary.
  • Incorporate a blend of high-press and low-press questions into the third turn. Write question starters on a post-it note or index card as a visual cue.
  • Revoice students’ comments to build connection, elaborate on their ideas, or model vocabulary and technical terms.
  • Offer elaborative feedback to provide explanation or offer strategic information, clarify misconceptions, or guide students to make corrections.
  • Explicitly name and model third-turn strategies for students and encourage them to intentionally practice using third-turn talk moves in discussions.
  • Be conscious of not taking full responsibility for the third turn. Use wait time to give students the opportunity to use talk moves to keep the discussion flowing.

FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: INTEGRATING READING AND WRITING INSTRUCTION

Oct
17

This is the first post in the series From Research to the Classroom, designed to bridge the gap between educational research and classroom practice. Each post will feature a key study and offer practical, research-backed strategies for immediate classroom use. Our aim is to provide educators with clear, actionable insights that translate the latest findings into effective teaching practices, directly supporting student learning and enhancing instruction

The Sciences of Reading and Writing Must Become More Fully Integrated by Steve Graham (Reading Research Quarterly, 2020)

“Science has greatly enhanced what we know about reading and writing. Drawing on this knowledge, researchers have proffered recommendations for how to teach these two literacy skills. Although such recommendations are aimed at closing the gap between research and practice, they often fail to take into account the reciprocal relation that exists between reading and writing. Writing and writing instruction improve students’ reading and vice versa.”

Summary

Steve Graham contends that the sciences of reading and writing are too narrowly focused on how to teach either reading or writing rather than how they can be used to support one another. He argues that recommendations for literacy instruction drawn from science often fail to take advantage of the reciprocal relationship that exist between reading and writing.

Graham provides theoretical support for reading and writing connections by drawing on three perspectives:

  1. Shared Knowledge Theory: readers draw on knowledge while reading that overlaps with knowledge they draw on when writing and vice versa.
  2. Rhetorical Relations Theory: the purpose of both reading and writing is communication and both processes involve a conversation between the reader and writer (the reader with the writer and the writer with the assumed reader).
  3. Functional Theory: reading can be used to facilitate writing and vice versa and both can be used to facilitate learning.

Graham also presents empirical evidence of the impact of reading and writing connections by sharing the findings of two meta-analyses that confirm reading and writing are connected and mutually supportive:

Writing and Writing Instruction Improve Reading

A meta-analysis of 95 true and quasi-experiments exploring whether writing and writing instruction improve the reading performance of students in grades 1-12 revealed that reading comprehension is enhanced by:

  • writing about the material read
  • increasing the amount of time students spent writing their own texts (journal entries, self-selected topics, personal experiences, emails, etc.)
  • writing instruction on process, functions and features of text, paragraphs, and sentences

Reading and Reading Instruction Improve Writing

A meta-analysis of 92 studies designed to identify whether reading and reading instruction positively impact the writing performance of students in preschool to grade 12 concluded that writing performance is made better by:

  • increasing students’ interactions with texts
  • devoting more time to reading instruction, including phonological awareness, phonics, and reading comprehension

Conclusion

Although Graham is clear that he is not advocating that we abandon studying reading and writing separately, he is proposing that researchers contributing to the current discourse around the sciences of reading and writing place a greater emphasis on the relationship between reading and writing and how it can support students’ development as readers and writers.

Takeaways For the Classroom

  • Increase time for students to read and write.
  • Increase time spent on reading and writing instruction.
  • Explicitly identify for students the ways reading and writing processes are mutually supporting. For example:
    • After a lesson on writing with clarity, remind students when they are reading independently to attend to the strategies they notice the writer using to make their ideas clear.
    • Follow up a lesson on using text structures to support comprehension with an opportunity to practice using similar structures to organize their writing.
    • Create lessons that combine reading and writing by having students notice and name the craft of a mentor text, discuss how it impacts their reading, and then experiment with the same techniques in their writing.
  • Encourage students to explore the conversation between reader and writer by reflecting on the intentional craft moves they made in their writing to engage their reader and by reading text through the lens of what it says and how it says it.
  • Integrate writing and reading by inviting students to write about their reading (notemaking, summaries, response, reflections, etc.)
  • Design larger units such as text sets and form, craft, and process studies that combine reading and writing.