FROM RESEARCH TO THE CLASSROOM: MULTICOMPONENT READING INTERVENTION
“Using a supplemental, multicomponent reading intervention to increase adolescent readers’ achievement” by Margaret Osgood Opatz and Sarah Kocherhans (The Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy, 2024)
“Instructional guidelines recommend implementing multicomponent interventions, those that address multiple reading skills (e.g., word analysis, fluency), because they yield better results than isolated skill interventions (Edmonds et al., 2009). Isolated skill intervention is insufficient for reading mastery, particularly for secondary students, who are expected to apply decoding skills to challenging text (Archer et al., 2003; Scammacca at al., 2007). Once students master decoding, other factors become more prominent in their reading development (Buckingham, 2020). While content courses in secondary schools place high expectations on students’ reading comprehension, foundational skills may impede students’ achievement. Therefore, it is imperative that adolescent readers progress toward proficient reading quickly, and that interventions target all of the major aspects of reading, as informed by research on effective practices.”
Summary
In this article, Osgood Opatz and Kocherans share the results of their study on the impact of a yearlong multicomponent small group reading intervention on the reading achievement of 7th grade students reading below grade level.
They situate their research within the unique reading demands placed on adolescent readers: “By middle school, readers are confronted with complex, disciplinary texts that differ markedly from everyday language and are, therefore, more cognitively demanding.” Adolescent comprehension relies heavily on the integration of linguistic and cognitive processes:
- decoding multisyllabic words
- comprehending increasingly complex language, including understanding vocabulary, various sentence constructions, and disciplinary strategies
- morphological awareness to unpack the meaning in condensed words
- syntactic awareness to identify the way phrases and clauses within sentences work together to construct meaning
- integrating background knowledge and making inferences
Osgood Opatz and Kocherans base the components of their multicomponent model on the four recommendations made in the Providing Reading Interventions for Students in Grades 4–9 Educator’s Practice Guide. These include interventions focused on multisyllabic words, fluency, and comprehension with materials that include complex, connected text. For secondary readers, interventions should focus on complex text reading with appropriate supports, fluency, multisyllabic word reading, and vocabulary with interspersed comprehension work.
Scaffolding complex text reading: Students should engage with connected, complex text, which is at least one grade level above their instructional reading level to maximize gains.
Fluency: In addition to assisted reading of complex text, repeated reading of the same text improves reading fluency.
Multisyllabic word reading: Instruction in syllable types and vowel sounds equips adolescent readers with word analysis skills they can apply as they encounter complex texts in any content area classes, which ultimately supports fluency.
Vocabulary: Intervention must target highly frequent, academic vocabulary to support comprehension and it must incorporate vocabulary review to provide multiple, meaningful exposures.
Comprehension: Open-ended comprehension questioning should be incorporated throughout the passage-reading portions of an intervention to support and deepen students’ Understanding.
While typical students would be expected to improve their reading ability by 1 year during a school year, it is critical that students reading below grade level improve at a faster rate to close the gap. The participants in this study reported growth equivalent to more than 1 year.
Takeaways For the Classroom
- Avoid isolated skill instruction and leverage multicomponent strategy instruction that focuses on fluency, word reading, vocabulary, and comprehension.
- Provide students with scaffolds that allow them to access and to practice in challenging grade-level complex texts.
- Leverage the interdependent relationship between reading strategies by modelling and practicing how readers use them flexibly.
- Prioritize acceleration by developing necessary scaffolds for students to engage with complex text and not the remediation of isolated skills dissociated from authentic text.
- Use PLC time to co-plan consistent multi-component instruction and intervention for students across all disciplines.
Conclusion
“Adolescent learners who enter secondary school reading below grade level have generally experienced years of reading instruction that has failed them. The gaps in foundational knowledge may vary widely between students, due to the differing instruction received in the elementary grades. To best support adolescent learners, intervention must target multiple areas in which reading failure may occur while simultaneously immersing students in complex text, as complex text reading prepares students for the text they will encounter in content area classes.”